On the contribution of literature and the arts to the educational cultivation of moral virtue, feeling and emotion. Dec 26, 20 peter thomas geach, philosopher, born 29 march 1916. Geach on logic and virtues 539 establish the need for faith. Wittgenstein and was frequently invited to take philosophical walks with. The original gave the date of the humanae vitae encyclical as 1962. The virtues the stanton lectures by peter geach apr 21, 1977.
Essays in honour of peter geach and elizabeth anscombe ed. Peter thomas geach, the virtues, stanton lectures 197374 cambridge. He studied classics and philosophy at balliol college, oxford, where, in 1938, he converted to roman catholicism. Discusses four cardinal virtues of prudence, justice, temperance, and courage, and the three theological virtues of faith, hope and charity. Virtues in foot and geach the philosophical quarterly.
Peter geach s the virtues 1977, foots article virtues and vices 1978, and, most decisively, alasdair macintyres after virtue 1981 that virtue ethics identified itself as a third alternative in the debate in normative ethics between deontological theories and utilitarian or consequentialist theories. Author bio peter geach is the author of numerous volumes, including god and the soul, providence and evil, and the virtues. Peter thomas geach, ma, fba born 29 march 1916 is a british philosopher with areas of interest in the history of philosophy, philosophical logic, and the theory of identity. Psychology, philosophy of mind publisher routledge and kegan paul. Not all religious conservatives are likely to lament the success of colorado and washingtons referenda legalizing the recreational use of marijuana. Claims moral precepts are absolute, utilitarianism is to be shunned, and sex apart from marriage is poison. Peter thomas geach fba 191620 was an english philosopher who was professor of logic at the university of leeds. Logic of the greatest happiness principle by alexander. Anscombe 19192001 in 1941 and went on to take up academic posts at the university of birmingham until 1966 and the university of. For instance, elizabeth anscombe and peter geach did as much as anybody to push back against the depsychologisation of ethics, and frequently with prominent reference to the virtues even though they were natural law theorists. Why men need the virtues faith hope charity prudence justice temperance courage. Peter geach project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. In the moral virtues and theological ethics notre dame, indiana. George geach was married to eleonore sgnonina, the daughter.
Virtues in foot and geach, the philosophical quarterly, volume 52, issue 209, 1 october 2002, pages 621631. World heritage encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive. The resulting notion turns out to have precisely those theoretical virtues that geach advertised. Com, including a parody of bennetts book by tony hendra with the selfcontradictory title the book of bad virtues 1994. Instead, geach spends most of his time defending the virtues both theological and cardinal against various objections.
Pdf peter geach mental acts m1 lophisc paris sorbonne. Dec 12, 2016 peter geach has a weird criticism of benthams utilitarianism in his book the virtues. Christoph luetge peter loscher chair of business ethics, technische universitat. The major themes of this chapter are developed from a couple of pages of an article of mine, virtues, motivation, and the end of life, in l. Geach my first task will be to draw a logical distinction between two sorts of adjectives, suggested by the distinction be tween attributive adjectives e. He objects to having the greatest happiness for the greatest number as the ultimate moral aim. In 2, by contrast, dispositions to look a certain way are. Geach against the more conventional twopremise account of modus ponens is that if we needed to supply ifp, then q as a premise for the inference of q from p, then by parity of reasoning we should need to supply if both p and if p then q, then q as a. Relative virtue, the southern journal of philosophy 10. Perhaps the most wellknown of anscombes contentions in modern moral philosophy is her. Both philippa foot and peter geach have put us in their philosophical debt to an unusual extent over an unusual. This sentence, however, contains an implicit reference to a noun. Now if he is right and the poisonousness of nonmarital sexual activity is a thing clearly visible, mary geach writes, and if marital sexual activity is not poisonous on the. Pdf critics of virtue ethics have argued that its focus on character rather than action, as well as its rejection of universal rules of right action.
This shows in the fact that such sentences cannot be split. Jan 19, 2014 peter geach, who has died aged 97, was a formidable logician and happened to be married to one of the 20th centurys leading englishlanguage philosophers, elizabeth anscombe. Geach s most popular book is translations from the philosophical writings of gottlob. Simon believes that behind the laymans understanding of these notions. Hardcover the virtues the stanton lectures by peter geach apr 21, 1977. He was the only son of george hender geach and his wife eleonora frederyka adolfina nee sgonina. Simon believes that behind the laymans understanding of these notions of temperance and the other moral virtues extolled. In angloamerican philosophy, peter geach s the virtues.
Virtues and vices of marijuana use matthew schmitz first. Geach put the frege point to use in arguing against, among other views, performative analyses of ethical sentences. The resulting notion turns out to have precisely those theoretical virtues that geach. Peter geach s distinction between logically predicative and logically attributive adjectives has become part of the technical apparatus of philosophers, but no satisfactory explanation of what an attributive adjective is has yet been provided. In this volume of newly commissioned essays, leading moral philosophers offer a comprehensive overview of virtue ethics. Peter geach 1977 international journal for philosophy of religion 12 4. Platos shorter ethical works stanford encyclopedia of. Both philippa foot and peter geach have put us in their philosophical debt to an unusual extent over an unusual length of time. Virtues and vices of marijuana use matthew schmitz. Discusses four cardinal virtues of prudence, justice. During these cambridge years geach attended the lectures of. Geach s discussion suggests two different ways of understanding the notion. Aristotle said that a virtue is a trait of character manifested in habitual action.
Peter geach 191620 455 eter geach was born on march 29, 1916. Thomistic virtue based ethics, pioneered by elizabeth anscombe and peter geach. Peter geach recommended conceiving of god as almighty, not as omnipotent. Pdf on obligation and the virtues of law matthew o. Peter thomas geach 191620 peter geach was born on 29 march 1916 at 41, royal avenue, chelsea. I shall borrow this termi nology from the grammars. He was the son of george hender geach, a cambridge graduate working in the indian educational service ies, who later taught philosophy at lahore. An examination of some medieval and modern theories contemporary philosophy by p. Moreover, this trend in not limited to the cultureatlarge. Meanwhile a number of interesting articles on the topic have come out in the journals. In angloamerican philosophy, peter geach s the virtues 1977 and, more importantly. This was often done by people sympathetic to virtue ethics, and almost always done with reference to the virtues.
He taught at the university of birmingham from 1951 until 1966. Relative virtue relative virtue vorobej, mark 19841201 00. The statement that an act x was voluntary, or intentional, or done with intent, or the like, on the part of an agent a has often been analyzed as a causal statement that x was initiated by. Virtue ethics has emerged from a rich history, in which both aristotle and aquinas have played an important role, to become one of the fastestgrowing fields in contemporary ethics. We ought, i think, to judge about cannabis indica as much as we judge about alcohol. The noted english catholic philosopher peter geach, for example, offered a thomistic defense of toking in his book the virtues. Virtues in foot and geach by alasdair macintyre natural goodness. Reciprocity and virtue ethics the university of chicago press.
Peter geach was born in chelsea, london, on 29 march 1916. A human action may be bad either if it springs from a vicious disposition, produces certain bad consequences or violates a rule. His responses are to varying degree chapter 1 of geach s book is titled, why men need the virtues, a phrase that is explained by claiming that the virtues are needed for most important endeavors in human life not. Virtue theory and the present evolution of thorn ism. Gertrude elizabeth margaret anscombe stanford encyclopedia. International journal for philosophy of religion 12 4. The book of virtues and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. Essays in honour of peter geach and elizabeth anscombe dublin. Geach on logic and virtues summary peter geach s book, the virtues, reflect his mastery of logic. Dec 10, 2020 in this respect, she agrees with peter geach in claiming that human beings need virtues as bees need stings foot 2001, 44. Pdf on obligation and the virtues of law matthew obrien. Mental acts routledge, 1957, god and the soul routledge, 1969, and his 197374 stanton lectures the virtues. The sort of performative analysis with which geach was concerned gave the meaning of a predicate like is good by saying that this predicate is used not to describe some object or event as having a certain property. Geach is one of the strongest advocates of a virtue based ethical.
530 88 585 1488 1568 1376 686 177 1480 201 1784 140 1745 1522 1412 825 1295 1076 654 1046 852 1181 1503 1392 137 1835 1736 409 914 1090 671 99